As we approach another pivotal election year, investors often find themselves caught in a whirlwind of speculation about how the stock market might react. Will it soar with one party’s victory or plummet with another’s? It’s a tantalizing question that has captivated market watchers for generations. But before you start rearranging your portfolio based on political prognostications, let’s take a closer look at what history actually tells us about stocks and election months.
The S&P 500 Index, stretching back to 1926, offers us a unique vantage point to examine how stocks have behaved during election seasons. This rich historical dataset, spanning nearly a century of market performance, reveals some surprising insights that challenge common assumptions about elections and market performance.
The Myth of Partisan Market Performance
Contrary to popular belief, the stock market doesn’t play favorites when it comes to political parties. The data reveals no consistent pattern of stock performance based on which party wins the presidential election. In fact, when we look at the distribution of returns for the S&P 500 Index from January 1926 to December 2023, we see a remarkable similarity between election months where Democrats won, months where Republicans won, and non-election months.
A Closer Look at the Numbers
Let’s break down the data into specific ranges of returns:
- Large Market Drops (Below -10%): These are rare across the board, but they do occur. The data shows instances of drops between -20% to -10% happening in both election and non-election months, with no clear partisan trend.
- Moderate Losses (-10% to 0%): The frequency of moderate losses is fairly consistent across all three categories. For instance, returns between -5% to -4% appear with similar frequency whether a Democrat won, a Republican won, or it was a non-election month.
- Modest Gains (0% to 5%): This is the most common outcome across all months. The chart shows a high concentration of returns in the 0% to 1% and 1% to 2% ranges for all three categories, indicating that small positive returns are the norm regardless of elections.
- Substantial Gains (5% to 10%): While less common than modest gains, these occur with similar frequency across all types of months. Returns between 5% to 6%, for example, show up in months when both parties won and in non-election months.
- Large Market Gains (Above 10%): These are the least common but still present across all categories. The data shows instances of returns above 20% in both election and non-election months, again with no clear partisan advantage.
What This Means for Investors
The key takeaway from this comprehensive data set is clear: the stock market’s performance in election months is remarkably similar to its behavior in any other month. This suggests that while elections are undoubtedly important for many reasons, their impact on short-term market performance may be overstated.
Instead of trying to time the market based on election outcomes, investors would be wise to focus on their long-term financial goals and maintain a well-diversified portfolio. After all, the market’s long-term trajectory has been upward, regardless of which party occupies the White House.
Conclusion
As we’ve seen, the relationship between elections and stock market performance is far more complex than simple partisan narratives suggest. The data spanning nearly a century shows that while elections can certainly create short-term volatility, they don’t dictate long-term market trends. The key to navigating these waters is a sound, personalized investment strategy that aligns with your goals and risk tolerance.
At Purposeful Wealth Advisor, we specialize in helping our clients cut through the noise of market speculation and political punditry. Our team of experienced advisors can work with you to develop a robust, long-term investment plan that stands strong regardless of election outcomes. We use data-driven approaches, like the historical S&P 500 performance we’ve discussed, to inform our strategies and help you make confident decisions.
We are here so you can approach election years with confidence, knowing your investment strategy is built on solid historical foundations rather than political speculation. Let us know if you would like to chat!
Interested in more?
Click here to uncover additional insights from the infographic.
